Exploring Allegory in the Mystic Gospel: Morton Smith’s Insights

Morton Smith, known for his controversial discovery and interpretation of the "secret" gospel, offers intriguing perspectives on allegorical readings of gospel passages. Scott Brown's recent paper delves into Smith's exploration of Mark 10:13–45 and the enigmatic Mystic Gospel (LGM 1), shedding light on Smith's attempt to uncover deeper meanings through allegory.

Smith's Homiletic Approach

In his seminal works on the secret gospel, Morton Smith initially approached Mark 10:13–45 and LGM 1 with a homiletic lens, viewing these passages as symbolic of baptismal rites for neophytes. This interpretation focuses on the outward teaching and ritual aspects within a community context.

Smith's Allegorical Musings

However, Scott Brown reveals a lesser-known facet of Morton Smith's thinking, captured in annotations found in his copy of Clement of Alexandria and a Secret Gospel of Mark. Smith pondered the possibility of an allegorical reading, considering how deeper spiritual truths might be encoded within these texts.

An Allegorical Framework

Smith's speculative notes suggest an allegorical framework where the narrative unfolds as a spiritual journey: from the revelation of divine law (Mark 10:17–19) to humanity's response and spiritual death (LGM 1:1), culminating in divine intervention and resurrection (LGM 1:1–7). This progression mirrors a symbolic journey towards enlightenment and freedom from legalistic constraints (LGM 1:10–12).

Clementine Connections

Interestingly, Smith's musings diverge from Clement of Alexandria's more systematic allegorical approach. Unlike Clement, Smith did not integrate LGM 2 into his homiletic reading, hinting at different interpretative paths. Scott Brown suggests that Smith's speculations lacked the Alexandrian depth found in Clement's writings, which systematically connect allegorical interpretations to broader theological frameworks.

Conclusion

Scott Brown's study illuminates Morton Smith's engagement with allegorical readings of the Mystic Gospel, contrasting his homiletic approach with Clement of Alexandria's systematic theological allegory. While Smith's insights offer a glimpse into alternative interpretive strategies, they underscore the unique depth and coherence of Clement's allegorical readings within early Christian thought.

For further exploration of Scott Brown's insights into Morton Smith's thoughts on the Mystic Gospel, read the full paper here: Scott Brown's Paper on Academia.edu.

---

This blog post encapsulates Scott Brown's findings on Morton Smith's contemplation of allegorical readings in the Mystic Gospel, highlighting contrasts with Clement of Alexandria's systematic theological approach.