The Opening of the Marcionite Text in Plain Sight?
Cyril of Jerusalem and the Marcionite Gospel
Cyril of Jerusalem, in his Catechetical Lectures (3.6), references the beginning of the gospel narrative:
"The end he was of the Prophets: for all the Prophets and the law were until John: but of the Gospel history he was the first-fruit. For it says, The beginning of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, John came baptizing in the wilderness."
Here, Cyril describes the transition from the prophets to the gospel with John the Baptist’s sudden appearance as a significant marker. This aligns with the Marcionite understanding, where the gospel begins not with a birth narrative but with the advent of John the Baptist. This abrupt start is also reflected in the Marcionite gospel, emphasizing a clear departure from Judaic traditions and focusing on the new revelation through Jesus.
Clement of Alexandria’s Gospel Citations
Clement of Alexandria provides another piece of the puzzle. He cites the Gospel of Luke as beginning with:
"And in the fifteenth year, in the reign of Tiberius Caesar, the word of the Lord came to John, the son of Zacharias... And Jesus was coming to His baptism, being about thirty years old."
Clement's description suggests a gospel that starts with John the Baptist and moves directly to Jesus' baptism, skipping the infancy narratives. This structure resonates with what is known of the Marcionite gospel, which Marcion is said to have derived from an early, possibly pre-Lukan version of the Gospel of Luke.
Marcionite Gospel as a Harmony?
Cyril of Jerusalem hints that Marcion might have corrupted a gospel harmony:
"and Marcion, that mouthpiece of ungodliness. For he who proclaimed different gods, one the Good, the other the Just, contradicts the Son when He says, O righteous Father... Marcion first, that most impious of men, who first asserted three Gods, knowing that in the New Testament are contained testimonies of the Prophets concerning Christ, cut out the testimonies taken from the Old Testament, that the King might be left without witness."
Cyril’s criticism points to Marcion selectively editing the gospel to fit his theological agenda, removing Old Testament references to create a purer form of what he believed to be the true gospel. This act of cutting and pasting could suggest that the Marcionite gospel was indeed a refined version of an existing harmony, retaining core elements like the beginning with John the Baptist.
The Controversy of Secrecy
One of the key criticisms against the Marcionite gospel is its secretive nature. Critics argue that such secrecy goes against the open proclamation of the gospel message. However, if we consider the context of early Christian mysticism and the esoteric traditions present in many religious movements, the idea of a secret gospel becomes less far-fetched. The secrecy aligns with Marcion’s emphasis on special revelation and the distinction between the hidden, true God and the creator God of the Old Testament.
Patristic Evidence of a Secret Gospel
Early church fathers, including Tertullian and Irenaeus, mention a Pauline secret gospel, which fits the description of the Marcionite gospel. Clement’s tentative assignment of his "secret gospel" to Mark suggests a connection to the Marcionite tradition, especially considering that Origen repeatedly links the beginning of Mark’s gospel to the Marcionite gospel.
Conclusion
The evidence from Cyril of Jerusalem and Clement of Alexandria, combined with patristic testimonies, supports the hypothesis that the Marcionite gospel began with John the Baptist, mirroring the structure found in the Gospel of Mark. The secretive nature and selective editing further align it with Marcion’s theological goals. While definitive proof remains elusive, the pieces of the puzzle fit together to suggest that the opening of the Marcionite gospel has been hiding in plain sight within the writings of early church fathers.
Comments
Post a Comment